A probation review should not be the first time a new hire hears about a concern. When it is, the review feels like an ambush and the record is thin. The evidence should have been collected at the agreed checkpoints.
A probation review pack makes the conversation predictable.
Agree the Checkpoints at the Start
Record the review dates, the criteria, and the person responsible. Share them with the new hire in the first week.
Criteria should be specific to the role and the agreed objectives, not a generic list.
Collect Evidence Along the Way
At each checkpoint, record the objectives discussed, the examples observed, the feedback given, and the support provided. Keep the notes factual and dated.
Do not wait until the review to reconstruct the last three months.
Separate Support From Assessment
Record what the manager did to support the new hire: training, shadowing, check-ins, and adjustments. A fair review shows both the expectation and the support.
Prepare the Pack
The pack should include the objectives, the checkpoint notes, the new hire's self-assessment if used, and the manager's summary. Give the new hire the pack in advance.
Hold the Conversation
The manager leads the review. The coordinator can schedule it, prepare the pack, and record the outcome. The decision about continuation belongs to the authorized manager and HR process.
Handle the Common Situations
A concern appears late. Record when it was identified and what support was offered. Do not backdate the feedback.
The new hire disputes a note. Record the disagreement and the evidence. Correct factual errors.
The manager has not completed the checkpoints. Record the gap and route it to the manager's manager before the review.
An extension is proposed. Record the reason, the new date, and the objectives for the extension.
Review the Process
Sample completed probation reviews and check that the checkpoints occurred, the evidence is specific, and the new hire received the pack in advance. The pattern shows whether the process is real or ceremonial.
For employment and performance context, see the Society for Human Resource Management.
Continue building the workflow
Related support: Manager onboarding task reliability, Onboarding feedback loop. The SHRM Official program context for onboarding administration..
Related reading
Make Manager Onboarding Tasks Reliable
A manager task list with due dates and evidence so the new hire's first month does not depend on memory.
Build an Onboarding Feedback Loop That Changes Something
A feedback loop that collects new hire input, routes it to owners, and tracks whether the process actually changed.
